Home Case Study

Grain Valley School District’s Transition to Propane-Powered School Buses for Enhanced Fleet Efficiency and Cost Savings

Grain Valley School District’s Transition to Propane-Powered School Buses for Enhanced Fleet Efficiency and Cost Savings

Nov 13, 2024 <h1>Grain Valley School District’s Transition to Propane-Powered School Buses for Enhanced Fleet Efficiency and Cost Savings</h1>

Background

Grain Valley School District, located in the suburban region of Kansas City, Missouri, operates a fleet of 49 buses that transport over 3,500 students across its rapidly expanding area. With a growing student population and increasing demands on the transportation system, the district faced rising operational costs and a strained transportation budget. Additionally, state reimbursements for school transportation were significantly reduced, putting more pressure on the district to find cost-effective solutions.

In an effort to address these financial challenges while also considering environmental sustainability, Grain Valley School District decided to explore alternative fuel options. Their goal was to maintain a high standard of transportation services while reducing costs, lowering maintenance requirements, and minimizing environmental impact. After evaluating various options, the district chose propane autogas as the fuel of choice for its new buses.

Challenges

The district faced several key challenges with its traditional diesel-powered bus fleet:

  1. Rising Maintenance Costs: The aging diesel buses in the fleet required frequent maintenance, including costly repairs for engines, fuel systems, and exhaust filters. The maintenance expenses associated with diesel vehicles were putting a considerable strain on the district’s transportation budget.

  2. Fluctuating Diesel Prices: Diesel fuel prices were subject to volatility, making it difficult for the district to accurately forecast fuel expenses and plan budgets effectively. The high and unpredictable cost of diesel was a major factor prompting the district to seek more stable fuel options.

  3. Environmental and Health Concerns: Diesel buses emit high levels of particulate matter and nitrogen oxides, both of which contribute to air pollution and can have adverse health effects, particularly on children. As a result, the district was motivated to consider cleaner fuel options that would provide a healthier environment for students, drivers, and the community.

 

Solution

In 2018, after thorough research and consultations with industry experts, Grain Valley School District made the decision to transition part of its fleet to propane autogas buses. Propane autogas was chosen for several reasons:

  • Cost-Effectiveness: Propane is significantly cheaper than diesel, allowing the district to reduce fuel expenses.

  • Lower Maintenance Requirements: Propane engines tend to be simpler and cleaner, which leads to reduced maintenance costs and less engine wear.

  • Environmental Benefits: Propane is a clean-burning fuel, emitting lower levels of greenhouse gases, nitrogen oxides, and particulate matter.

The district initially purchased 14 propane-powered buses, followed by an additional 7 buses in 2020, bringing the total number of propane buses to 21. This shift required an infrastructure investment, so the district partnered with Ferrellgas, a national propane supplier, to install an onsite propane fueling station equipped with two 1,000-gallon tanks, a dispenser, and a card reader system for efficient fuel tracking and management.

 

Implementation

The transition to propane-powered buses involved several key steps to ensure a smooth integration into the district’s fleet:

  1. Infrastructure Development: The district worked with Ferrellgas to build a propane fueling station on school grounds, creating a convenient and efficient fueling process. The installation included the necessary tanks, dispensers, and monitoring systems to ensure that fueling was quick, safe, and efficient. The onsite fueling station eliminated the need for drivers to travel to offsite fuel stations, saving both time and fuel.

  2. Driver and Staff Training: Transitioning to propane required training for both drivers and maintenance staff. Drivers were trained on how to safely operate propane-fueled vehicles and use the new fueling system. Maintenance staff received education on propane engine systems, including their unique requirements and benefits compared to diesel engines. This training ensured that the team could maintain the new buses effectively and safely.

  3. Maintenance Planning and Scheduling: With propane’s cleaner combustion properties, the district developed a new maintenance schedule that extended service intervals for engine oil changes, fuel filter replacements, and emissions-related repairs. The reduced maintenance requirements not only saved costs but also increased vehicle uptime, ensuring that the buses were available for regular routes with minimal downtime.

 

                                     

 

 

Results

The transition to propane autogas buses yielded impressive results for the Grain Valley School District, both financially and environmentally:

  1. Significant Cost Savings: During the 2018-2019 school year, the district reported a fuel savings of over $14,500 compared to their previous diesel costs. Additionally, the district was eligible for the Alternative Fuel Tax Credit, which provided an additional $0.50 per gallon of propane used. This resulted in an extra $21,719 in federal rebates, substantially reducing the overall cost of fuel.

  2. Reduced Maintenance Needs: Propane engines are simpler than diesel engines, with fewer complex parts such as particulate filters, selective catalytic reduction systems, and exhaust gas recirculation valves. As a result, the propane buses required fewer repairs and experienced less downtime. The district estimated that maintenance costs for propane buses were approximately 20% lower than those for diesel buses, contributing to significant cost savings over time.

  3. Improved Environmental Impact: Propane is a cleaner-burning fuel, producing 96% fewer nitrogen oxides (NOx) than diesel and 60% fewer greenhouse gas emissions. By switching to propane, the district reduced its environmental footprint, contributing to cleaner air in the community. This change also promoted a healthier environment for students, as propane buses emit significantly lower levels of particulate matter, which can affect respiratory health.

  4. Enhanced Reliability and Uptime: With reduced maintenance needs and less time spent in the shop, the propane buses were consistently available for daily routes. This reliability was crucial for the district, as it ensured that students could rely on timely transportation to and from school. The improved uptime also allowed the district to meet growing demand for student transportation without needing additional vehicles.

  5. Positive Public Relations: The district’s shift to propane autogas buses was well-received by the community, showcasing Grain Valley’s commitment to sustainability and fiscal responsibility. The transition was highlighted in local news, providing positive visibility for the district and reinforcing its role as an environmentally-conscious community leader

 

Challenges and Lessons Learned

While the transition to propane buses was successful, the district encountered a few challenges along the way:

  • Initial Infrastructure Investment: Setting up the onsite fueling station required a substantial initial investment. However, the long-term fuel savings and federal tax credits helped offset these costs. Grain Valley also found that partnering with an experienced propane supplier, such as Ferrellgas, was crucial in managing the setup efficiently.

  • Staff Training Needs: Switching from diesel to propane required comprehensive training for drivers and maintenance staff. Grain Valley emphasized the importance of well-planned training sessions to ensure a smooth transition and maximize the benefits of the new fuel system.

 

Conclusion

Grain Valley School District’s transition to propane autogas buses showcases the potential of alternative fuels to create a cost-effective and environmentally friendly fleet. By switching to propane, the district significantly reduced fuel and maintenance costs, minimized its carbon footprint, and improved vehicle reliability. This success story highlights the importance of adopting a proactive approach to fleet management, where alternative fuels and efficient operations contribute to financial sustainability and environmental responsibility.

With a fleet management solution like ayefleet, other school districts can streamline and optimize similar transitions. Ayefleet offers advanced tracking, maintenance scheduling, and real-time data insights that make fleet management straightforward and efficient. For districts considering alternative fuels, ayefleet’s predictive maintenance and fuel management tools ensure smooth fleet operations, reduced maintenance costs, and enhanced uptime. Ayefleet empowers districts to monitor vehicle health, automate maintenance reminders, and track fuel usage—critical for sustaining an eco-friendly, cost-effective transportation system for students.

 

References

Productivity & Efficiency
Related

Some of our case studies